“Descendants of the Executioners” in the Space of Memory about the Era of Political Repressions (on the example of the Project “The Investigation of Karagodin”)
pdf (Русский)

Abstract views: 88
PDF Downloads: 43

Keywords

Memory
Trauma
Repression
Victims
Executioners
Descendants of the Victims
Descendants of the Executioners
Moral Community
Memory Studies
Discourse of Memory

How to Cite

Zevako, Y. (2022). “Descendants of the Executioners” in the Space of Memory about the Era of Political Repressions (on the example of the Project “The Investigation of Karagodin”). Galactica Media: Journal of Media Studies, 4(2), 41-64. https://doi.org/10.46539/gmd.v4i2.265

Abstract

This article is devoted to the problem of the place of “descendants of the executioners” in the space of memory of the era of political repression. The article discusses questions about the attitude of the “moral community” that has developed around the victims of repression and their descendants towards the “descendants of the executioners” – on the example of the analysis of the case with D. Karagodin’s project “The Investigation of KARAGODIN”. The study shows that the specified moral community, using the mechanism of dehumanization in relation to the “executioners” (as a mechanism for constructing the image of the enemy), tends to transfer these characteristics to their descendants – despite the fact that, for the most part, the “descendants of the executioners” are “honest descendants”, since they practically do not know / did not know anything about the professional activity and specific actions of their ancestors. Differences were also revealed, causing tension between the acceptable and unacceptable reactions prescribed by the moral community to kinship with the “executioners” and the variety of real experiences of the “descendants of the executioners”. The article analyzes the semantic aspects of the concept of “descendants of executioners”. The author of the article shows that these semantic aspects are often built on different grounds and can intersect, giving rise to internal conflicts including those of ethical nature. The article concludes that the “descendants of the executioners” (“honest descendants”) today are actually not represented in the space of memory of the era of political repression. In the context of increasing government influence to the memory of the era of political repression, and, as a result, of increased tension between the state and the moral community, representatives of this community are not always ready to perceive the voices of the “descendants of the executioners”, who are often associated with modern representatives of the state, alongside with the voices of “descendants of the victims”. All these circumstances significantly complicate the formation of “symmetrical memory” as a condition for successful processing of the difficult past.

https://doi.org/10.46539/gmd.v4i2.265
pdf (Русский)

References

“Denis Karagodin” (group publications), Facebook group**. (2020-2021). https://www.facebook.com/groups/112567742111900/user/587106474 (In Russian)

“The KARAGODIN Inquiry” (Investigation into the fate of Stepan Ivanovich KARAGODIN – born 1881, murdered by the NKVD on 21 January 1938). (2012). https://karagodin.org/ (In Russian)

“They crossed a political line”. Son of NKVD officer - on why he wrote a statement against the repression investigator. (2021). https://vot-tak.tv/novosti/03-03-2021-son-nkvd-oppression/ (In Russian)

An act of civil concord and reconciliation. (2016). https://karagodin.org/?p=11119 (In Russian)

Assmann, A. (2014). The Long Shadow of the Past: Memorial Culture and Historical Politics. New Literary Review. (In Russian)

Buller, A., & Linchenko, A. A. (2015). Forgiveness? On the phenomenon of historical unforgiveness and intransigent memory. Philosophy questions, 11, 50–59. (In Russian)

Comments on the post in the CARAGODIN Investigation group. (2021, May 14). Facebook**. https://www.facebook.com/KARAGODINorg/posts/3944646352271860 (In Russian)

Dorman, V. (2010). From Solovki to Butovo: The Russian Orthodox Church and the Memory of Soviet Repression in Post-Soviet Russia. Laboratorium: Journal of Social Research, 2, 327–347. (In Russian)

Epple, N. (2021). An inconvenient past of state crimes in Russia and elsewhere. New Literary Review. (In Russian)

Fursov, K. K. (2015). Enmity discourse: Concept and contemporary practices. Discourse-Pi, 1, 25–30. (In Russian)

Gerasimenko, O. (2021, May 4). “The prosecutor's office makes a lot more sense than Memorial*”. As Denis Karagodin searches for the truth about his great-grandfather's execution. BBC Russian Service. https://www.bbc.com/russian/features-57089858 (In Russian)

Gorin, V. (2021, March 6). Karagodin strikes back. Meduza***. https://karagodin.org/?p=37801 (In Russian)

Goroshko, E. I. (2012). Modern Internet Communications: Structure and Main Characteristics. In Internet communication as a new speech formation (pp. 9–52). Flinta, Nauka. (In Russian)

Izard, C. E. (2012). The psychology of emotions. Piter. (In Russian)

Kolezev, D. (2021, December 3). The trauma of Stalinism. How the memory of the Great Terror affects power and society in contemporary Russia. A conversation with Nikolai Apple. Republic***. https://republic.ru/posts/102498 (In Russian)

Kurilla, E. (2016). Name the executioners. How the memory of the past is being revived in Russia. KARAGODIN Investigation. https://karagodin.org/?p=7617 (In Russian)

Lushnikov, D. A. (2018). Dehumanization and demonization as mechanisms of enemy image formation in negative information campaigns. Poisk: Politics. Social Studies. Art. Sociology. Culture, 5, 116‑122. (In Russian)

Plumper, J. (2018). A history of emotion. New Literary Review. (In Russian)

Ponomariova, A. (2016, November 23). Find the executioners, forgive the descendants. Radio Svoboda***. https://www.svoboda.org/a/28134691.html (In Russian)

Prudnikova, Y. I. (2010). Commentary as a tool to reflect the language picture of the world. Izvestia of the Samara Scientific Centre of the Russian Academy of Sciences, 12(5–3), 793–797. (In Russian)

Ryzhkina, N., & Lyutova, E. (2021, March 4). “My father is not an executioner, he has awards!”: Son of NKVD officer writes statement against great-grandson of executed Siberian. Moskovsky Komsomolets. https://www.nsk.kp.ru/daily/27247/4376858/ (In Russian)

Son of NKVD officer accused us of discrediting his father's name. (2021, March 3). KARAGODIN Investigation. https://karagodin.org/?p=37706 (In Russian)

Trubitsyna, L. V. (2005). The trauma process. Smysl; CheRo. (In Russian)

Ushakin, S. (2014, November 14). Remembering in Public: On the Affective Management of History. Memory that has fallen out of time: Russia's official constructions of memory. GEFTER. http://gefter.ru/archive/13513 (In Russian)

Vezhnovets, E. A. (2016). Commentary in Social Networks: The Production and Reproduction of Internet Discourse. Modern discourse analysis, 2, 35–58. (In Russian)

Volchek, D. (2016, June 18). There has been a murder. Radio Svoboda***. https://www.svoboda.org/a/27803161.html (In Russian)

Volchek, D. (2017, March 18). “Your great-grandfather was a mass murderer”. Radio Svoboda***. https://www.svoboda.org/a/28375447.html (In Russian)

Volchek, D. (2018, March 17). “We poke a stick into the mouth of the beast”. A conversation with the great-grandson of a Chekist. Radio Svoboda***. https://www.svoboda.org/a/29101852.html (In Russian)

*An organization recognized in Russia as a foreign agent and liquidated by decision of the Supreme Courts of the Russian Federation

** A social network recognized in Russia as belonging to an extremist organization.

*** Mass media recognized in Russia as a foreign agent.

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.